The NFL is supposed to be the ultimate meritocracy, where talent and skill win out over all other concerns. That’s not necessarily the case, though – and sometimes the league is even more unfair than the outside world.
Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Penix Jr. has cause to gripe as much as anybody. A top-10 overall pick after a couple of brilliant seasons at Washington, Penix came into the league having to play behind a 35-year old quarterback who was never going to be Atlanta’s franchise starter of the future. As a result, Penix wound up only starting three games his rookie season.
Last season Penix was bitten by the injury bug, cutting his 2025 season short to nine games. So, even though he’s been in the NFL two years he’s only earned 12 starts – and has had a difficult time building momentum and getting into rhythm with his receivers.
Now heading into 2026 Penix has to compete with Tua Tagovailoa for the QB1 job, and is among the 10 players around the league with the most at stake, according to Pro Football Focus.
“In light of Penix’s performance as well as a season-ending ACL tear, the team took a flier on Tua Tagovailoa in free agency. Much like his draft classmate McCarthy, Penix must not only reclaim QB1 status, but also needs to demonstrate better precision to avoid difficult conversations about his future in Atlanta. It’s important to consider that the Falcons’ new regime was not present when Penix was drafted, which means the threshold for moving on may be shorter.”
Penix does do some things better on the field than Tagovailoa, including throwing outside the hashes and unleashing deep passes. However, Tua’s advantages are piling up and by all accounts he seems to be in the lead in the Falcons’ ongoing quarterback competition.
There’s a good chance that Penix will once again begin the season on the sidelines, and will be lucky to wind up starting half a season again.
If Penix is ever going to live up to the potential he showed in college, he’s going to need a long string of consecutive starts to get into rhythm with his receivers and comfortable with the speed of the NFL game. It’s beginning to look like that opportunity may never come in Atlanta.
This article originally appeared on Falcons Wire: Michael Penix Jr. facing pressure this year, per Pro Football Focus
About the Author
